Criminal Law Protection of the Autonomy of Patients in Ukraine: Analysis of Possible Grounds for Criminal Liability. Part 2

Sofiya Likhova, Marek Mozgawa

Abstract


The aim of the article is to analyze the phenomenon of “patient’s autonomy” as an object of criminal law protection. The article is divided into two parts. In this part, attention is focused on discussing possible grounds for criminal liability in case of violation of patient’s autonomy. It should be stressed that, of course, only some of the behaviors violating the legal good of patient’s autonomy is regulated by criminal law and may therefore result in criminal liability. The authors analyze offences whose commission by medical personnel may violate patient’s autonomy. In addition, they present statistics on the number of medical crimes for 2019.


Keywords


patient’s autonomy; criminal liability; offences; medical personnel; criminal law protection

Full Text:

PDF

References


LITERATURE

Berylo O.H., Kryminalna vidpovidalnist za nenadannya dopomohy khvoromu medychnym pratsivnykom, Kyyiv 2018 (dysertatsiya kandydata yurydychnykh nauk).

Berylo O.H., Osoblyvosti rehulyuvannya suspilnykh vidnosyn shchodo vidpovidalnosti za nenadannya dopomohy khvoromu medychnym pratsivnykom u period Kyyivskoyi Rusi. Kryminolohichna teoriya ta praktyka: dosvid, problemy sohodennya ta shlyakhy yikh vyrishennya: materialy muzhvuz, Kyyiv 2017.

Bortnyk N., Didkivska G., Tylchyk V., The impact of international labour migration on the development of states under globalization: economic and legal aspects, “Baltic Journal of Economic Studies” 2018, vol. 4(2), DOI: https://doi.org/10.30525/2256-0742/2018-4-2-47-52.

Burdin V.M., Osoblyvosti kryminalnoyi vidpovidalnosti likariv za nenadannya dopomohy khvoromu. Problemy derzhavotvorennya i zakhstu pravy lyudyny v Ukrayini, Lviv 2004.

Chebotarova H.V., Kryminalno-pravovi problemy transplantatsiyi orhaniv abo tkanyn lyudyny ta donorstva krovi, Kyyiv 2003 (dysertatsiya kandydata yurydychnykh nauk).

Dutchak S., Fenomen absolyutnoy viktimnosti patsiyenta v Ukraine, “Legea si viata” 2017 (April).

Fil I.M., Farmatsevtychnyy pratsivnyk yak subyekt zlochynu, peredbachenoho st. 140 KK Ukrayiny, “Chasopys Kyyivskoho universytetu prava” 2013, no. 3.

Illyashenko O.V., Zapobihannya nezakonniy torhivli orhanamy i tkanynamy lyudyny v Ukrayini ta inshykh Yevropeyskykh krayinakh (porivnyalno-pravove doslidzhennya), Kyyiv 2008 (avtoref. dys. na zdobuttya nauk. stupenya kand. yuryd. nauk).

Likhova S., Mozgawa M., Сriminal Law Protection of the Autonomy of Patients in Ukraine. Part 1, “Studia Iuridica Lublinensia” 2021, vol. 30(4), DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.17951/sil.2021.30.4.373-391.

Plotnikova V., Faktory latentizatsii prestupleniy v sfere meditsinskoy deyatelnosti, “Vestnik Natsionalnoy akademii prokuratury Ukrainy” 2011, no. 2.

Shopina Y.O., Criminal liability of a medical or pharmaceutical worker for an offense connected with performance of professional duties, Kyiv 2020 (abstract of candidate thesis in legal sciences).

Shopina Y.O., Kryminalna vidpovidalnist medychnoho abo farmatsevtychnoho pratsivnyka za vchynennya zlochynu, povyazanoho z vykonannyam profesiynykh obovyazkiv, Kyyiv 2020 (dysertatsiya kandydata yurydychnykh nauk).

Yasenytskyy V.Y., Kvalifikatsiya zlochyniv, shcho posyahayut na prava patsiyenta, [in:] Aktualni problemy derzhavy i prava, eds. S.V. Kivalov, Yu.M. Oborotov, L.R. Bila, Odesa 2005.

Yazukhin A.N., Spornyye voprosy kvalifikatsii prestupnykh deystviy meditsinskikh rabotnikov. Voprosy sovershenstvovaniya ugolovno-pravovogo regulirovaniya: mezhvuzov, Sb. Nauch. Tr. Sverdlovsk, 1988.

Zherzh L.A., Kryminalno-pravova kharakterystyka ta zapobihannya shchlochynam, povyazanym z nezakonnoyu transplantatsiyeyu, Irpin 2021 (dysertatsiya na zdobuttya naukovoho stupenya doktor filosofiyi u haluzi prava).

Zherzh L.A., Rozmayita V.V., Determinanty koruptsiyi u diyalnosti medychnykh pratsivnykiv. Fiskalna polityka: teoretychni ta praktychni aspekty yurydychnoyi nauky: zb. tez, Irpin 2018.

Zherzh N.A., Zherzh L.A., Melnychenko A.O., Zapobihannya vchynennyu zlochyniv u sferi torhivli lyudmy v Ukrayini. Kryminolohichna teoriya i praktyka: dosvid, problemy sohodennya ta shlyakhy yikh vyrishennya, Kyyiv 2017.

ONLINE SOURCES

Additional Protocol to the Convention on Human Rights and Biomedicine, concerning Biomedical Research, Strasbourg, 25.01.2005, Council of Europe Treaty Series, no. 195, https://rm.coe.int/CoERMPublicCommonSearchServices/DisplayDCTMContent?documentId=090000168008371a [access: 20.09.2021].

Andriyovych K.A., 500 000 hrn. za invalidnist dytyny vnaslidok nedbalosti likariv Verkhovnyy sud vyznav dostatnim vidshkoduvannyam (VS/KTSS no. 520/16987/15-ts vid 04.09.2019), https://protocol.ua/ru/vs_ktss_500_000_grn [access: 20.09.2021].

Andriyovych K.A., Nevirno postavlenyy diahnoz, vstanovlennya yakoho potyahlo za soboyu obrannya nepravylnoyi taktyky likuvannya, tyahne za soboyu kryminalnu vidpovidalnist (VS/KKS no. 127/16872/17 vid 02.10.2018), https://protocol.ua/ru/sud_nevirno_postavleniy [access: 20.09.2021].

Lisitsyna Y.O., Porushennya vstanovlenoho zakonom poryadku transplantatsiyi orhaniv abo tkanyn lyudyny ta nasylnytske donorstvo: kryminalno-pravova ta kryminolohichna kharakterystyka, Lviv 2016 (dysertatsiya na zdobuttya naukovoho stupenya kandydata yurydychnykh nauk), http://dspace.lvduvs.edu.ua/bitstream/1234567890/466/1/lisitsina%20dus.pdf [access: 10.11.2021].

Nuremberg Code, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuremberg_Code [access: 20.09.2021].

Office of the Attorney General, www.gp.gov.ua/ua/1stat [access: 20.09.2021].

Office of the Attorney General, www.gp.gov.ua/ua/index.html [access: 20.09.2021].

Osoblyvosti prytyahnennya likariv do kryminalnoyi vidpovidalnosti, 2019, https://protocol.ua/ru/osoblivosti_prityagnennya_likariv_do_kriminalnoi_vidpovidalnosti [access: 20.09.2021].

Palytsya Y.V., Tsikavi fakty z istoriyi farmatsiyi, https://nubip.edu.ua/sites/default/files/u125/cikavi_fakti_z_istoriyi_farmaciyi.pdf [access: 10.11.2021].

Palytsya Y.V., Tsikavi fakty z istoriyi likoznavstvo, https://nubip.edu.ua/sites/default/files/u125/cikavi_fakti_z_istoriyi_likoznavstva.pdf [access: 10.11.2021].

Pochemu vrachi ne otvechayut za svoi oshibki?, http://paralleli.if.ua/news/5500.html [access: 10.06.2021].

Radutskyy M., Transplantatsiya: yak vylikuvaty ukrayinskykh patsiyentiv ta pochaty zaroblyaty na inozemtsyakh, 2020, https://life.pravda.com.ua/columns/2020/06/4/241214 [access: 10.06.2021].

Tema 1. Kvalifikatsiya zlochyniv proty zhyttya ta zdorova osoby, https://arm.naiau.kiev.ua/books/kval-ok-zlochuniv-25-04-207/lectures/lecture_1.html [access: 20.09.2021].

Zozulya N., Osoblyvosti prytyahnennya likariv do kryminalnoyi vidpovidalnosti, 2019, https://protocol.ua/ru/osoblivosti_prityagnennya_likariv_do_kriminalnoi_vidpovidalnosti [access: 10.11.2021].

LEGAL ACTS

Nakaz, Instruktsiya of 25 September 2000, no. 226, Pro zatverdzhennya normatyvno-pravovykh dokumentiv z pytan transplantatsiyi MOZ Ukrayiny.

Nakaz Ministerstva okhorony zdorovya Ukrayiny of 22 July 2002, no. 323, Pro zatverdzhennya formy medychnoyi oblikovoyi dokumentatsiyi “Kartka donora rezervu” ta instruktsiyi shchodo yiyi zapovnennya.

Nakaz Ministerstva okhorony zdorovya Ukrayiny of 23 September 2013, no. 821, Pro vstanovlennya diahnostychnykh kryteriyiv smerti mozku ta protsedury konstatatsiyi momentu smerti lyudyny.

Postanovoyu Kabinetu Ministriv Ukrayiny of 18 December 2019, no. 1083, Pro zatverdzhennya pereliku posluh ta taryfiv na posluhy z nadannya tretynnoyi (vysokospetsializovanoyi) medychnoyi dopomohy metodom transplantatsiyi orhaniv ta inshykh anatomichnykh materialiv, yaki nadayutsya uchasnykamy pilotnoho proektu shchodo zminy mekhanizmu finansovoho zabezpechennya operatyvnoho likuvannya z transplantatsiyi orhaniv ta inshykh anatomichnykh materialiv.

Zakon Ukrayiny of 23 June 1995, no. 239/95-VR, Pro donorstvo krovi ta yiyi komponentiv.

Zakon Ukrayiny of 5 July 2012, no. 5081-VI, Pro ekstrenu medychnu dopomohu.

Zakon Ukrayiny of 17 May 2018, no. 2427-VIII, Pro zastosuvannya transplantatsiyi anatomichnykh materialiv lyudyni.




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.17951/sil.2021.30.5.391-411
Data publikacji: 2021-12-17 19:45:24
Data złożenia artykułu: 2021-02-28 15:08:30


Statistics


Total abstract view - 639
Downloads (from 2020-06-17) - PDF - 0

Indicators



Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Copyright (c) 2021 Sofiya Likhova, Marek Mozgawa

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.