The non-market aspect of the economy of the Republic of Moldova

Maciej Kowalczyk

Abstract


The purpose of the article is a scientific trial of a description of the economy of the Republic of Moldova, operating mainly in the area subject to jurisdiction of the government in Chisinau, but also partnering with enterprises from the separatist region of Transnistria, whose participants have developed a business model based on personal relations, circumventing or violating applicable laws and using state property to generate revenues at a level that would be difficult to achieve in conditions of the rule of law, competition and market saturation with operating anticorruption services. The explanation focuses on a description of politicians and entrepreneurs Vladimir Plahotniuc and Ilan Șor, cases of leading Moldovan enterprises and the gambling industry. The challenge for the researcher is the availability of official documents and data. The analysis focuses on documents, media coverage and events that were subject of a wider public discussion. The information and opinions collected in the course of the research process allow for an attempt to assess the scale of the takeover of the Moldovan economy by certain interest groups, as well to observe actions aimed at counteracting corruption and reducing retributions of public-law liabilities.


Keywords


Market, competition, economy, Republic Moldova, Chisinau, Plahotniuc, Șor, gam- bling, sanctions, Magnitsky Act

Full Text:

PDF (Język Polski)

References


Bibliogrfia

Typ bibliografii:

Dokumenty; artykuły w Internecie

Dokumenty

Infotag Analytics, wydanie 2 (549), opublikowane 22.01.2020 r.

Infotag Analytics, wydanie 5 (650), opublikowane 02.02.2022 r.

Infotag Analytics, wydanie 6 (651), opublikowane 09.02.2022 r.

Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights, REPUBLIC OF MOLDOVA, PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION, 1 and 15 November 2020, ODIHR Limited Election Observation MissionFinal Report, https://www.osce.org/files/f/

documents/1/5/479972.pdf, data dostępu na 08.09.2022 r.

Infotag Analytics, wydanie 34 (679), opublikowane 24.08.2022 r.

https://danubeports.eu/images/11_Tucher-Mathias von_GIFP_Danube_Ports_Day_17_Nov_2020_

compressed.pdf, data dostępu 20.08.2022 r.

Infotag Analytics, wydanie 40 (685), opublikowane 12.10.2022 r.

Государственная монополия наазартные игры: как российские нелегальные офшоры зарабатывают на несовершенном законодательстве республики Молдова https://legal-monitor.md/en/assets/img/pdf-files/Short_presentationRU.pdf, data dostępu 03.08.2022 r.

State monopoly on gambling games: how russian illegal offshore companies make money on the imperfect legislation of the republic of moldova, https://legal-monitor.md/en/assets/img/Doc/Research_offhoreEN.docx, data dostępu 03.08.2022 r.

Comisia pentru Situa{ii Excepfionale a Republicii Moldova, https://cancelaria.gov.md/sites/default/files/

dispozitia_cse_a_rm_nr.21_din_18.05.2022.pdf, data dostępu 26.11.2022 r.

https://www.parlament.md/StructuraParlamentului/Deputa%c8%9bii/tabid/87/Id/818/language/en-US/Default.aspx, data dostępu 26.11.2022 r.

Moldova's gambling black market, https://legal-monitor.md/en/projects/piata-gri-jocuri-de-noroc, opublikowane 19.05.2022 r.

HOTĂRÂRE Nr. 371, din 24-05-2011,cu privire la crearea Societăţii pe Acţiuni „Loteria Naţională a Moldovei” https://www.legis.md/cautare/getResults?doc_id=1807〈=ro, opublikowane 24-05-2011, data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.

HOTĂRÂRE Nr. HG639/2017, din 14.08.2017, cu privire la aprobarea obiectivelor și a condițiilor parteneriatului public-privat pentru dezvoltareaactivităților SA „Loteria Națională a Moldovei”, precum și a cerințelor generale privind selectarea partenerului privat, data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.

https://www.legis.md/cautare/downloadpdf/101587, opublikowane 14.08.2017, data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.

LEGE Nr. 257, din 16-12-2020, cu privire la modificarea unor acte normative, https://www.legis.md/cautare/

getResults?doc_id=124566〈=ro, data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.

Comunicat, http://www.lnm.md/uploads/editor/946f5d7b33040d86e17f50b4d0982a54.pdf, data dostępu 04.08.2022 r.

Sociological study.Moldavian citizens perception of lotteries and sports Betting, April 2022, https://legal-monitor.md/en/assets/img/pdf-files/sondajEN.pdf, data dostępu 04.08.2022 r.

Infotag Analytics, wydanie 43 (688), opublikowane 02.11.2022 r.

Global Magnitsky Act, https://www.state.gov/global-magnitsky-act, data dostępu 02.11.2022 r.

Global Magnitsky Sanctions, https://home.treasury.gov/policy-issues/financial-sanctions/sanctions-programs-and-country-information/global-magnitsky-sanctions, data dostępu 02.11.2022 r.

Artykuły w Internecie

https://www.metalferos.md, data dostępu 10.02.2022 r.

https://www.aommz.com/en, data dostępu 10.02.2022 r.

https://sheriff.md, data dostępu 10.02.2022 r.

https://ro.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ceslav_Ciuhrii, data dostępu 09.09.2022 r.

https://satulgerman.md, data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.

https://pl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natalia_Gordienko, data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.; https://www.instagram.com/natalitsa, data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.

https://regata.md, data dostępu 20.08.2022 r.

https://www.maib.md/en, data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.

http://www.audiovizual.md, data dostępu 12.10.2022 r.

https://gifp.md/en/operator-page, data dostępu 20.08.2022 r.

https://www.facebook.com/DanubeLogistics;

https://www.linkedin.com/company/ics-danube-

logistics-srl, data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.

https://www.dnb.com/business-directory/company-profiles.danube_logistics_holding_

bv.f0498da4dde2b950d3071c38f3cd87cb.html; data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.

https://www.danube-logistics.info, data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.

https://rocketreach.co/ics-bemol-retail-srl-profile_b5ce3d84f42e0918, data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.

In response to the EBRD's press release, BEMOL RETAIL is providing following statement, https://www.ipn.md/en/in-response-to-the-ebrds-press-release-bemol-retail-is-providing-following-state-7542_1080556.html, opublikowane 23.03.2021 r.; data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.

BEMOL accused of manipulating public opinion, https://timpul.md/language/en/articol/bemol-accused-of-manipulating-public-opinion-166567.html, data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.

Mathias von Tucher appointed as general director of Danube Logistics SRL, https://gifp.md/en/news/

mathias-von-tucher-appointed-as-general-director-of-danube-logistics-srl, 21.03.2019 r. data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.;

https://rocketreach.co/mathias-von-tucher-email_22189757, Mathias VON TUCHER, data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.

https://www.danubeports.eu/19-governance/advisory-group/49-thomas-moser, data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.

I. Ernst, EBRD takes over operator of Moldova’s sole port, https://www.intellinews.com/ebrd-takes-over-operator-of-moldova-s-sole-port-210908, opublikowane 20.05.2021 r., data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.;

Bemol Retail a câştigal definitiv procesul judiciar în Ţările de Jos, https://www.mold-street.com/?go=news&n=12689, opublikowane 15.09.2021 r., data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.;

O. Cotruța, Bemol Retail a câștigat definitiv procesul judiciar în Olanda. Portul Giurgiulești s-ar putea întoarce proprietaruluiui, https://bani.md/bemol-retail-a-castigat-definitiv-procesul-judiciar-in-olanda-portul-giurgiulesti-s-ar-putea-intoarce-proprietaruluiui, opublikowane 15.08.2021 r. data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.;

ECO-BUS weekly digest, https://www.ipn.md/en/eco-bus-weekly-digest-7966_1081833.html, opublikowane 24.05.2021 r. data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.;

EBRD details investment in Moldova’s Giurgiuleşti Port, https://www.ipn.md/en/ebrd-details-investment-in-moldovas-giurgiulesti-port-7966_1082672.html, opublikowane 29.06.2021 r. data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.;

EBRD becomes owner of Giurgiulesti International Free Port, https://www.ipn.md/en/ebrd-becomes-owner-of-giurgiulesti-international-free-port-7966_1081730.html, opublikowane 19.05.2021 r., data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.

EBRD and Giurgiulești International Free Port, https://www.ebrd.com/documents/admin/giurgiuleti-international-free-port.pdf?blobnocache=true, data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.

I. Gulca, M. Necșuțu, The war between Aliyev and Moser: How the Giurgiulesti International Free Port became EBRD property, https://anticoruptie.md/en/investigations/economic/the-war-between-aliyev-and-moser-how-the-giurgiulesti-international-free-port-became-ebrd-property, opublikowane 21.05.2021 r.; data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.

Thomas Moser refutes rumors about acquisition of giurgiulesti port shares, http://www.infotag.md/economics-en/279357, 01.10.2019 r.; data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.

Statement of Thomas Moser, http://www.infotag.md/press_release_en/279349, opublikowane 01.10.2019 r. data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.;

Thomas Moser: Rafiq Aliyev is attempting to coerce me into agreeing to the sale of Danube Logistics Holding BV, https://timpul.md/language/en/articol/thomas-moser-rafiq-aliyev-is-attempting-to-coerce-me-into-agreeing-to-the-sale-of-danube-logistics-holding-bv-147350.html, data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.’

Bemol:Ȋndemn cărte Dl. Thomas Moser să respecte Republica Moldova şi legile acestaia, https://www.mold-street.com/?go=news&n=11814, opublikowane 02.03.2021 r., data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.;

M. Necșuțu, Investigație: Cum a ajuns Portul Internațional Liber Giurgiulești din Republica Moldova în proprietatea BERD. Războiul dintre oamenii de afaceri Rafiq Aliyev și Thomas Moser, https://www.g4media.ro/investigatie-cum-a-ajuns-portul-international-liber-giurgiulesti-din-republica-moldova-in-proprietatea-berd-razboiul-dintre-oamenii-de-afaceri-rafiq-aliyev-si-thomas-moser.html, opublikowane 21.05.2021 r., data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.;

Îndemn către Dl.Thomas Moser să respecte Republica Moldova și legile acesteia,

https://realitatea.md/indemn-catre-dl-thomas-moser-sa-respecte-republica-moldova-si-legile-acesteia, opublikowane 03.03.2021 r., data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.

https://airport.md/en/contacts/airport-history#block3, data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.

https://profiles.rise.md/profile.php?id=200313094412; data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.;

https://profiles.rise.md/profile.php?id=200313094412〈=eng, data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.;

https://qoobus.com/en/company/md/societateacuraspunderelimitataaviainvest-__-1013600025635, data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.;

https://www.data2b.md/ro/companies/1013600025635/srl-avia-invest, data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.;

https://b2bhint.com/en/company/md/avia-invest-srl--1013600025635, data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.;

https://seenews.com/companies/company_profile/avia-invest-srl-425485, data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.;

M. Necsutu, Rothschild Company Abandons Bid to Run Moldova Airport, https://balkaninsight.com/2019/

/23/rothschild-company-abandons-bid-to-run-moldova-airport, opublikowane 23.12.2019r, data dostępu 08.08.2024 r..

Public Property Agency sues Avia Invest, https://www.ipn.md/en/public-property-agency-sues-avia-invest-7966_1073812.html, opublikowane 27.05.2020 r.; PPA increases amount claimed from Avia Invest,

https://www.ipn.md/en/ppa-increases-amount-claimed-from-avia-invest-7966_1074272.html, opublikowane 18.06.2020 r., data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.;

PPA asks Avia Invest to transfer back assets of Chisinau Airport,https://www.ipn.md/en/

ppa-asks-avia-invest-to-transfer-back-assets-of-chisinau-7966_1074793.html, opublikowane 10.07.2020 r., data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.;

Ion Chicu about “Avia Invest”: We consider it didn’t fulfill obligations, https://www.ipn.md/en/ion-chicu-

about-avia-invest-we-consider-it-didnt-7967_1074800.html. opublikowane 11.07.2020 r., data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.

Igor Munteanu: We did not find confirmation that "Avia Invest" would have invested its own money in the Airport, https://www.ipn.md/en/igor-munteanu-we-did-not-find-confirmation-that-avia-invest-7967_1068672.html, 08.10.2019r., data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.;

“Avia Invest” asked to present cost basis for airport charges,

https://www.ipn.md/en/avia-invest-asked-to-present-cost-basis-for-airport-charges-7966_1072126.html, opublikowane

03.2020 r., data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.;

Avia Invest invested in airport primarily from current activity, PPA vice director, https://www.ipn.md/

en/avia-invest-invested-in-airport-primarily-from-current-activity-ppa-7966_1080448.html, opublikowane 19.03.2021 r., data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.

Avia Invest reacts to request made by Civil Aviation Administration, https://www.ipn.md/en/

avia-invest-reacts-to-request-made-by-civil-aviation-administration-7966_1072548.html, opublikowane 30.03.2020 r., data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.;

Avia Invest: Debts of over 22m lei represent part of penalties, https://www.ipn.md/en/

avia-invest-debts-of-over-22m-MDL-represent-part-of-7966_1073348.html, opublikowane 07.05.2020 r., data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.;

Request to annul termination of contract to concede airport rejected, https://www.ipn.md/en/

request-to-annul-termination-of-contract-to-concede-airport-rejected-7967_1088029.html, opublikowane 23.02.2022 r., data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.

Moldovan NGO seeks cancellation of Chisinau airport concession, http://www.infotag.md/reports-en/767771, 09.12.2013 r., data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.;

Government’s airport concession decision was taken with gross violation of legislation – human right activist, http://www.infotag.md/reports-en/767686, opublikowane 07.10.2013 r., data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.;

Avia Invest assets’ takeover cannot take place if it affects state interests, deputy, https://www.ipn.md/en/

avia-invest-assets-takeover-cannot-take-place-if-it-affects-7965_1067667.html, opublikowane 23.08.2019 r., data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.;

Maia Sandu: There was no consultation between Government and NR Investments Ltd., https://www.ipn.md/

en/maia-sandu-there-was-no-consultation-between-government-and-nr-7966_1067769.html, opublikowane 29.08.2019 r., data dostępu 08.08.2024 r. ;

Igor Munteanu: Concession of Chisinau Airport involved serious violations, https://www.ipn.md/

en/igor-munteanu-concession-of-chisinau-airport-involved-serious-violations-7965_1067782.html, opublikowane 30.08.2019 r., data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.;

Ministry of Economy will order an audit of investments made at airport,

https://www.ipn.md/en/ministry-of-economy-will-order-an-audit-of-investments-made-7966_1067798.html, opublikowane 30.08.2019 r., data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.;

Igor Munteanu tells which steps should be taken to cancel the airport concession contra, https://www.ipn.md/en/igor-munteanu-tells-which-steps-should-be-taken-to-cancel-7967_

html, opublikowane 03.09.2019 r., data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.;

Igor Munteanu: Any proposals coming from Rothschild are poisonous and cannot be accepted, https://www.ipn.md/en/igor-munteanu-any-proposals-coming-from-rothschild-are-poisonous-and-7967_1067935.html, opublikowane 07.09.2019 r., data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.;

Parliament asks the Government to start the procedure of cancelling the Airport concession, https://www.ipn.md/en/parliament-asks-the-government-to-start-the-procedure-of-cancelling-7966_1068612.html, opublikowane 04.10.2019 r., data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.;

Igor Dodon about decision made by NR Investments Ltd, https://www.ipn.md/en/

igor-dodon-about-decision-made-by-nr-investments-ltd-7965_1070472.html, opublikowane 23.12.2019 r., data

dostępu 08.08.2024 r.;

Airport concessionaires want more transactions to be performed with Avia Invest, opinion,

https://www.ipn.md/en/airport-concessionaires-want-more-transactions-to-be-performed-with-avia-7978_1070488.html, opublikowane 24.12.2019 r., data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.;

Court of Auditors: Concession of airport is an equation with many unknowns, https://www.ipn.md/en/court-of-auditors-concession-of-airport-is-an-equation-with-7967_1071041.html, opublikowane 24.01.2020 r., data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.;

Economy minister: Franchise agreement on airport can be terminated, https://www.ipn.md/en/economy-minister-franchise-agreement-on-airport-can-be-terminated-7967_1071276.html, opublikowane 05.02.2020 r., data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.;

Those to blame for concession to detriment of state should be identified, MP, https://www.ipn.md/en/those-to-blame-for-concession-to-detriment-of-state-should-7965_1071961.html, opublikowane 05.02.2020 r., data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.;

Approaches made to terminate contract with investor of Chisinau Airport, https://www.ipn.md/en/approaches-made-to-terminate-contract-with-investor-of-chisinau-airport-7965_1074787.html, opublikowane 10.07.2020 r., data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.;

Avia Invest: Concession contract is not and cannot be terminated, https://www.ipn.md/en/avia-invest-concession-contract-is-not-and-cannot-be-terminated-7966_1074794.html, opublikowane 10.07.2020 r., data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.;

Stockholm Arbitration Institute bans termination of contract for concession of airport, https://www.ipn.md/en/stockholm-arbitration-institute-bans-termination-of-contract-for-concession-of-7966_1075304.html, opublikowane 03.08.2020 r., data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.

Na podstawie informacji medialnych z datą dostępu 25.11.2022 r: http://www.infotag.md/m9_economics/303179/

https://www.ipn.md/ru/kishinevskiy-mezhdunarodnyy-aeroport-vozvrashchaetsya-v-sobstvennost-gosudarstva-7966_1093573.html

https://www.ipn.md/ru/avia-invest-reshenie-o-rastorzhenii-kontsessionnogo-dogovora-kishinevskogo-aerop-7966_1093574.html

https://noi.md/ru/obshhestvo/igori-muntyanu-koncessiya-ajeroporta-byla-prestupnoj-sdelkoj

https://noi.md/ru/politika/nataliya-gavrilica-litrówa-neobhodimye-ukazaniya-po-nemedlennoj-peredache-ajeroporta-v-gosupravlenie

DOC Chisinau International Airport included in list of assets that cannot be privatized, https://www.moldpres.md/en/news/2024/05/24/24003832, opublikowano 24.05.2024 r., data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.;

Aeroportul Chișinău nu mai poate fi privatizat: instituțiile publice au la dispoziție o lună pentru a ajusta actele; https://newsmaker.md/ro/aeroportul-chisinau-nu-mai-poate-fi-privatizat-institutiile-publice-au-la-dispozitie-o-luna-pentru-a-ajusta-actele/, opublikowano 24.05.2024 r., data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.

Aeroportul POATE fi privatizat. Curtea Constituțională a declarat neconstituțional amendamentul în acest sens votat de 55 de parlamentari, în cadrul ședinței din data de 21 mai, https://tvstar.md/aeroportul-poate-fi-privatizat-curtea-constitutionala-a-declarat-neconstitutional-amendamentul-in-acest-sens-votat-de-55-de-parlamentari-in-cadrul-sedintei-din-data-de-21-mai/, opublikowano 21.06.2024 r., data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.

https://www.transoilcorp.com, data dostępu 26.11.2022 r.

The Company History, https://www.transoilcorp.com/about-us/the-company-history, data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.

https://www.oaktreecapital.com, data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.

www.7777.md, data dostępu 20.07.2022 r.

https://www.lnm.md, data dostępu 03.08.2022 r.

Пошук по сайту: parimatch, https://antikor.com.ua/articles?search=parimatch, data dostępu 04.08.2022 r.

До уваги операторів, провайдерів телекомунікацій!, https://nkrzi.gov.ua/index.php?r=site%2Findex&pg=99&id=1870&language=uk&fbclid=IwAR3kZGEp3eOBf-7YoYf2BEYlKLeFLpaoTjMVKses_houAgsGfdkzfJRoNeo, data dostępu 04.08.2022 r.

Response to Corruption and Election Interference in Moldova, Press statement Antony J. Blinken, Secretary of State, https://www.state.gov/response-to-corruption-and-election-interference-in-moldova, opublikowane 26.10.2022 r., data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.

Treasury Targets Corruption and the Kremlin’s Malign Influence Operations in Moldova, https://home.treasury.gov/news/press-releases/jy1049, opublikowane 26.10.2022 r., data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.

C. Belton, Russia’s security service works to subvert Moldova’s pro-Western government, https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2022/10/28/russia-fsb-moldova-manipulation, opublikowane 28.10.2022 r., data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.

Interviu în exclusivitate cu Vladimir Plahotniuc - despre revenirea în politica moldovenească, https://tribuna.md/2022/10/28/interviu-in-exclusivitate-cu-vladimir-plahotniuc-despre-revenirea-in-politica-moldoveneasca, opublikowane 28.10.2022 r., data dostępu 08.08.2024 r.




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.17951/teka.2023.18.2.21-65
Date of publication: 2026-01-09 14:23:17
Date of submission: 2024-08-12 08:48:22


Statistics


Total abstract view - 27
Downloads (from 2020-06-17) - PDF (Język Polski) - 9

Indicators



Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Copyright (c) 2026 Maciej Kowalczyk

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.