“The Birds Do Not Sing Here...” (Russian Anti-War Songs)

Svetlana Shnitman-Mcmillin

Abstract


After 24 February 2022, anti-war songs emerged as a new phenomenon in Russian culture. They cover a variety of genres, from bardic song to rap, from travesty to tragedy. Songs containing clear anti-war stances reflect the shock of war, the tragic death of people, the destruction of culture and society in which the authors lived or with which they were spiritually connected before the attack on Ukraine, the end of an era in the existence of the Russian Federation. Anti-war songs mark a constantly expanding thematic field, and this article is only an early attempt to analyse and survey them. The presented text collection reveals the clear awareness among creative circles that after the war against Ukraine Russians will face the task of rebuilding their country on the wreckage of a failed state.

Keywords


war in Ukraine, anti-war songs, Russian culture, new genre

References


Abbulin 2023: Abbulin, Rustam. “A Court in St. Petersburg Banned the Song Oida by Oxymiron.” https://daily.afisha.ru/news/76815-sud-v-peterburge-zapretil-pesnyu-oyda-oksimirona/ (published 06.06.2023, accessed 30.06.2023). [In Russian: Аббулин Рустам. „Суд запретил песню Оксимирона Ойда!“]

Akhedzhakova 2022: Akhedzhakova, Liia. “Tell Gordeeva.” Interview by Katerina Gordeeva. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kamoil6ifrI (published 06.03.2022, accessed 12.07.2023). [In Russian: Ахеджакова, Лия. “Скажи Гордеевой.” Интервью брала Катерина Гордеева.]

Akhmatova 1921: Akhmatova, Anna. “Everything is plundered, betrayed, sold...” (1921). In Verses and Poems. Leningrad, 1976: 166. [In Russian: Ахматова, Анна. “Все расхищено, предано, продано...” Стихотворения и поэмы. Ленинград, 1976: 166.]

Belyi 2023: Belyi, Anаtolii. Interview by Sandzhar Khamidov. “Voice of America.” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=St4u4_4yTh4 (published 29.06.2023, accessed 06.06.2023). [In Russian: Белый, Анатолий. Интервью брал Санджар Хамидов. “Голос Америки”, 29.06.2023.]

Berkovich 2023: Berkovich, Evgeniya. “February.” Music by Sergei Nikitin. https://youtu.be/uG-WgnVdX4M (published 04.05.2023, accessed 20.06.2023). [In Russian: Беркович, Евгения. “Февраль.” Музыка С. Никитина, YouTube, 04.05.2023.]

Dronov 2022: Shaman (Dronov, Yaroslav). “I am Russian!” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FAPwIEWzqJE (published 22.07.2022, accessed 16.06.2022). [In Russian: Шаман (Дронов, Ярослав). “Я русский!” 22.07.2022.]

Galich 1963: Galich, Aleksander. “Small Diligent Waltz” (1963). https://www.culture.ru/poems/3470/staratelskii-valsok (accessed 12.09.2023). [In Russian: Галич, Александр “Старательный вальсок” (1963). Культура.РФ.]

Grebenshchikov, Black swan, 2023: Grebenshchikov, Boris. Bogrukinog. “Black swan.” https://bg-aquarium.bandcamp.com/album/--5 (released 14.09.2023, accessed 19.09.2023). [Гребенщиков, Борис. “Богрукиног. Черный лебедь”, 14.09.2023.]

Grebenshchikov, Don’t stand..., 2023: Grebenshchikov, Boris. Bogrukinog. “Do not stand...” https://bg-aquarium.bandcamp.com/album/--5 (released 14.09.2023, accessed 19.09.2023). [Гребенщиков, Борис. Богрукиног. „Не стой...“, 14.09.2023.]

Grebenshchikov, From January..., 2022: Grebenshchikov, Boris. “From January and to the first leaves...” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lo4v04hdmq8 (published 21.10.2022, accessed 06.01.2023). [In Russian: Гребенщиков, Борис. “От января до первой листвы...”, 21.10.2022.]

Grebenshchikov, I don’t know..., 2022: Grebenshchikov, Boris. “I don’t know why and who needs it.” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RBKQzCYuDBc (published 12.03.2022, accessed 10.10.2023). [In Russian: Гребенщиков, Борис. „Я не знаю, зачем...“]

Grebenshchikov, Interview 2022: Grebenshchikov, Boris. Interview by Maxim Kurnikov, Deutsche Welle. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bN8o9XE6a00 (published 02.11.2022, accessed 12.03.2023). [In Russian: Гребенщиков, Борис. Интервью брал Максим Курников. Deutsche Welle, 02.11.2022.]

Gudkov 2022: Gudkov, Alexander. “I am narrow...” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b7a1YSSoVk0 (published 30.08.2022, accessed 18.06.2023). [In Russian: Гудков, Аleksander. “Я узкий...”, 30.08.2022.]

Gurulev 2023: Gurulev, Andrei. “Skalpel” by G.German. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=onK6Po9zFcQ (published 11.06.2023, accessed 07.06.2023). [In Russian: Гурулев, Андрей. „Скальпель“ Г. Германа, 11.06.2022.]

Guseynov 2023: Guseynov, Gasan. Appearance in “Putin – Judas.” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vZi25n_04Aw (published 13.08.2023, accessed 28.08.2023). [In Russian: Гусейнов, Гасан. В передаче “Путин – Иуда!”, 13.08.2023.]

Ivashchenko & Vasilyev 2022: Vasilyev, Georgi & Aleksey Ivashchenko. IVASI. “THAT.” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G6BskUeXVdo (published 14.10.2022, accessed 15.11.2022). [In Russian: Васильев, Георгий & Иващенко, Алексей. Группа Иваси. „ОНО.“ 14.10.2022.]

Lavrov 2016: Lavrov, Sergei. Press-conference with Lamberto Zannier, OSCE. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UtOLMl0OKzo (published 11.08.2016, accessed 26.06.2023). [In Russian: Лавров, Сергей. Пресс-конференция с Ламберто Заньер, ОБСЕ. 11.08.2016.]

Lazarev 2023: Lazarev, Mikhail “Rise up, country!” https://news2.ru/story/663560/ (published 29.05.23, accessed 12.07.2023). [In Russian: Лазарев, Михаил. „Вставай, страна!“ Исп. Ян Осин, 29.05.23.]

Lebedev-Kumach 1941: Lebedev-Kumach, Vasilii. “Rise up, great country!” (1941). https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZhRN6OLXR4c (published 25.09.2014, accessed 18.07.2023). [In Russian: Лебедев-Кумач, Василий (стихи) & Александров, А. (муз.). “Вставай, страна огромная!”.]

Ligalize, ...!!!, 2023: Ligalize (Men’shikov, Andrei). “...!!! To your!!! Home!!!” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5754d66D3ck; (published 29.06.2023, accessed 04.07.2023). [In Russian: Лигалайз (Меньшиков, Андрей). “...!!! Вашему!!! Дому!!!” 29.01.2023.]

Ligalize, Hope for tomorrow, 2016: Ligalize (Men’shikov, Andrei). “Hope for tomorrow.” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IOmhLZVyapY (published 18.03.2016, accessed 18.07.2023). [In Russian: Лигалайз (Меньшиков, Андрей). “Надежда на завтра”, 30.06.2023.]

Ligalize, Interview 2023: Ligalize (Menshikov, Andrei). Interview by Iurii Dud. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h3bt79JUYak (published 20.07.2023, accessed 25.08.2023). [In Russian: Лигалайз (Меньшиков, Андрей). Интервью брал Юрий Дудь. Вильнюс, 20.07.2023.]

Ligalize, Peace!!!, 2023: Ligalize (Men’shikov, Andrei). “Pеаce!!! To your!!! Home!!!” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3JKkd_WTAZg (published 30.06.2023, accessed 28.07.2023). [In Russian: Лигалайз (Меньшиков Андрей). “Мир!!! Вашему!!! Дому!!!” 30.06.2023.]

Makarevich, Empty promises, 2022: Makarevich, Andrei. “Еmpty promises...” https://life.nv.ua/art/andrey-makarevich-spel-v-efire-ukrainskogo-kanala-video-50222623.html (published 06.03.2022, accessed 18.07.2023). [In Russian: Макаревич, Андрей. “Пустым обещаньям...” 06.03.2022.]

Makarevich, Foreign agent’s song, 2022: Makarevich, Andrei. “Foreign agent’s song.” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PMsu-7IyN3A (published 22.09.2022, accessed 21.06.2023). [In Russian: Макаревич, Андрей. “Песня иноагента.” 22.09.2022.]

Makarevich, I will tell you, 2022: Makarevich, Andrei. “I will tell you about the country...” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iitzv9Pai80 (published 23.10.2022, accessed 20.06.2023). [In Russian: Макаревич Андрей: “Я расскажу Вам про страну...” 23.10.2022.]

Makarevich, Silent againts, 2022: Makarevich, Andrei. “Silent against.” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qb_cGT8Buck (published 22.06.2022, accessed 26.06.2023). [In Russian: Макаревич, Андрей. “Молчащие против.” 22.06.2022.]

Makarevich, The song of a recruit, 2023: Makarevich, Andrei. “The song of a recruit.” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oLhOk3qlMCU04 (published 04.04.2023, accessed 26.06.2023). [In Russian: Макаревич, Андрей. “Песня мобилизованного.” 04.04.2023.]

Makarevich, When you are born..., 2022: Makarevich, Andrei. “When you are born, you do not choose your country.” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vDw_mHtd6PQ (published 13.03.2022, accessed 19.05.2022). [In Russian: Макаревич, Андрей. “Рождаясь, не выбирают страну.” 13.03.2022.]

Makarevich, Yesterday, at a forum..., 2018: Makarevich, Andrei. “Yesterday, at a forum...” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2csIqayYP8Y (published 20.10.2018, accessed: 20.05.2023). [In Russian: Макаревич, Андрей. “На форуме вчера...” 20.10.2018.]

Makarevich, You have been duped, solder, 2015: Makarevich, Andrei. “You have been duped, solder.” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xN_w6Yd0yL0 (published 17.05.2015, accessed 11.08.2022). [In Russian: Макаревич, Андрей. “Teбя обманули, солдат.” 17.05.2015.]

Marshak & Prokofiev 1950: Marshak, Samuil. “We do not need war!” in Sergei Prokofiev’s oratorio “On guard for peace”, 1950. https://vk.com/video28154437_171237856 (performed 23.04.2015, accessed 03.06.2023). [In Russian: Маршак, Самуил. “Нам не нужна война!” в: Прокофьев, Сергей. “На страже мира.” Оратория, 1950.]

Monetochka 2022: Monetochka (Gardymova, Elizaveta). “No to war!” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PbF_uktSH8o (published 17.05.2022, accessed 15.06.2023). [In Russian: Монеточка (Гардымова, Елизавета). “Нет войне!” 17.05.2022.]

Muratov 2023: Muratov, Dmitrii. Speech at Global Media Forum. Bonn, 20.06.2023. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vvAJPmJqvys (published 21.06.2023, accessed 17.09.2023). [In Russian: Муратов, Дмитрий. Речь на Международном Медиа Форуме. Бонн, 20.06.2023.]

Novaya Gazeta 2022: “Creeping GRAD”, 16.09.2022: https://novaya.media/articles/2022/09/16/grad-polzuchii (accessed 10.10.2023). [In Russian: “Град ползучий”, Новая Газета, 16.09.2022.]

Oblomov 2021: Oblomov (Goncharov), Vasilii. “Run, my friend, run!” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9FQCDt_uIt0 (published 06.04.2021, accessed 18.06.2023). [In Russian: Обломов (Гончаров), Василий. “Беги, дружище, беги!” 06.04.2021.]

Oblomov 2023: Oblomov (Goncharov), Vasilii. Interview by Mikhail Kozyrev, Channel “Rain”. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I34A5x5vnn0 (published 22.05.2023, accessed 22.09.2023). [In Russian: Обломов (Гончаров), Василий. Интервью брал Михаил Козырев. Канал “Дождь”, 22.05.2023.]

Okhlobystin 2022: Okhlobystin, Ivan. “Гойда!...” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ygbEqLfKF2Q (published 05.10.2022, accessed 18.12.2022). [In Russian: Охлобыстин, Иван. “Гойда...” 05.10.2022.]

Okudzhava 1975: Okudzhava, Bulat. “I am writing а historical novel.” https://www.culture.ru/poems/14268 (accessed 23.06.2023). [In Russian: Окуджава, Булат. “Я пишу исторический роман.” (1975).]

Oxxxymiron 2022: Oxxxymiron (Fedorov, Miron). “Oida!” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pYymRbfjKv8 (published 16.09.2022, accessed 24.06.2023). [In Russian: Oxxxymiron (Федоров, Мирон). “Ойда!” 16.09.2022.]

Pokrovskiy, Can you imagine, 2022: Pokrovskiy, Maxim. “Can you imagine…!” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EPxtglyqXeI (published 3.08.2022, accessed 18.11.2023). [In Russian: Покровский, Максим. „Вы представляете себе.“ 3.08.2022.]

Pokrovskiy, Generation Z, 2022: Pokrovskiy, Maxim. “Generation Z.” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uJEdIcitizQ (published 21.04.2022, accessed 05.05.2023). [In Russian: Покровский, Максим. “Поколение Z.” 21.04.2023.]

Pokrovskiy, Happy New Year, my son!, 2022: Pokrovskiy, Maxim & Mikhail Segal & Artur Smolianinov & Chulpan Khamatova. “Happy New Year, my son!” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y-W8w527oU4 (published 20.12.2022, accessed 16.03.2023). [In Russian: Покровский, Максим & M. Сегал & A. Смолянинов & Ч. Хаматова. “С Новым Годом, сынок!” 20.12.2022.]

Pokrovskiy, I do not need a war!, 2022: Pokrovskiy, Maxim. “I do not need a war!” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AwRp1rdFE-A (published 15.03.2022, accessed 18.06.2023). [In Russian: Покровский, Максим. “Нам не нужна война!” 15.03.2022.]

Pokrovskiy, Ukraine..., 2023: Pokrovskiy, Maxim. “Ukraine, my second half.” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SIY0wOKU9vY (published 24.02.2023, аccessed 11.06.2023). [In Russian: Покровский, Максим. “Украина, моя вторая половина.” 24.02.2023.]

Putin 2018: Putin, Vladimir. Speech at the Valdai Forum. https://ria.ru/20181018/1530999011.html (published 17.10.2018, accessed 26.12.2022). [In Russian: Путин, Владимир. Речь на Валдайском форуме. 17.10.2018.]

Putin 2022: Putin, Vladimir. Meeting with the mothers of soldiers, participating in Special Military Operation. http://kremlin.ru/events/president/news/69935 (published 25.11.2022, accessed 28.07.2023). [In Russian: Путин, Владимир. Встреча с матерями военнослужащих – участников СВО. 25.11.2022.]

Severov 2023: Severov, Igor. “To the Jews.” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zA8kbGULXOcс (published 28.01.2023, accessed 21.04.2023). [In Russian: Северов, Игорь. “К евреям!” 28.01.2023.]

Shevchuk, concert 2022: Shevchuk, Yuri. Concert in Ufa. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dit7y-VuX6g (published 19.05.2022, accessed 29.06.2023). [In Russian: Шевчук, Юрий. Концерт в Уфе. 19.05.2022.]

Shevchuk, Motherland..., 2022: Shevchuk, Yuri. “Motherland, come back home!” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k3Ncs0anYCI (published 12.07.2022, accessed 25.06.2023). [In Russian: Шевчук, Юрий. “Родина, вернись домой!” 12.07.2022.]

Shevchuk, Tell Gordeeva, 2022: Shevchuk, Yuri. “Tell Gordeeva.” Interview by Katerina Gordeeva. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k3Ncs0anYCI (published 12.07.2022, accessed 14.06.2023). [In Russian: Шевчук, Юрий. “Скажи Гордеевой.” Интервью брала Катерина Гордеева. 12.07.2022.]

Shevchuk, Wolves..., 2023: Shevchuk, Yuri. “Wolves in a shooting gallery.” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FffRH724Hro (published 14.07.2023, accessed 18.08.2023). [In Russian: Шевчук, Юрий. “Волки в тире.” 14.07.2023.]

Slepakov, It’s not all that clear-cut, 2022: Slepakov, Semyon. “It’s not all that clear-cut.” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FYizYh70KeU (published 27.09.2022, accessed 24.062023). [In Russian: Слепаков, Семен. “Не все так однозначно...” 27.09.2022.]

Slepakov, Lullaby, 2023: Slepakov, Semyon. “Lullaby.” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PNGCYGD0bWQ (published 24.01.2023, accessed 23.05.2023). [In Russian: Слепаков, Семен. “Колыбельная.” 24.01.2023.]

Slepakov, Nerusskiy, 2023: Slepakov, Semyon. “Nerusskiy.” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-66RXDhxcnk (published 9.11.2023, accessed 18.11.2023). [In Russian: Слепаков, Семен. “Нерусский.” 9.11.2023.]

Slepakov, No to vobla!, 2022: Slepakov, Semyon. “No to vobla!” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8Q_YfcpgdGU (published 14.10.2022, accessed 24.07.2023). [In Russian: Слепаков, Семен. “Нет вобле!” 14.10.2022.]

Slepakov, Patriot’s song, 2022: Slepakov, Semyon. “Patriot’s song.” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z7P1iAAvUio (published 02.10.2022, accessed 16.06.2023). [In Russian: Слепаков, Семен. “Песня патриота.” 02.10.2022.]

Tvardovsky 1946: Tvardovsky, Aleksandr. “I was killed near Rzhev.” (1946). https://www.culture.ru/poems/6907 (accessed 09.07.2023). [In Russian: Твардовский, Александр. „Я убит подо Ржевом...“ (1946).]

Vertinskiy 1917: Vertinskiy, Alexander. “I don’t know why and who needs it.” (1917). Sang by Boris Grebenshchikov: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RBKQzCYuDBc (published 12.03.2022, accessed 14.05.2022). [Вертинский, Александр. “Я не знаю, кому и зачем это нужно...” (1917). Исполняет Борис Гребенщиков, 12.03.2022.]

Voltskaya, Am I..., 2023: Voltskaya, Tatiana. “Am I living in a dream...” https://magazines.gorky.media/vestnik/2022/59/gde-ty-zhizn-poshla-na-slom.html (published 09.04.2022, accessed 19.08.2023). [In Russian: Вольтская, Татьяна. “То ли я живу во сне...” 09.04.2022.]

Voltskaya, My sons..., 2022: Voltskaya, Tatiana. “My sons...” https://www.svoboda.org/a/31735886.html (published 06.03.2022, accessed 18.08.2023). [In Russian: Вольтская, Татьяна. “Мои сыновья...” 06.03.2022.]

Voltskaya, Not a ballet..., 2022: Voltskaya, Tatiana. “Not a ballet...” https://www.facebook.com/tatiana.voltskaya/posts/pfbid02VX6PSVMEprTcyupuY3gSQK7YNFuDWwcDuc3x1us5RRJ8MLt4cjtCoxzR6E1p6Tzrl (published 05.05.2022, accessed 18.08.2023). [In Russian: Вольтская, Татьяна. “Ни балет...” 05.05.2022.]

Zemfira 2022: Zemfira (Ramazanova). “Do not shoot!” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r61TZZbT4FQ (published 09.11.2022, accessed 08.08.2023). [In Russian: Земфира (Рамазанова). “Не стреляйте!” 09.11.2022.]

|CMP|

Article submitted / Zgłoszony do Redakcji: 15.10.2023 | Reviews completed / Proces recenzyjny zakończony: 18.11.2023 | Accepted for publication / Przyjęty do publikacji: 22.11.2023 | Screened with iThenticate




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.17951/zcm.2023.12.44-71
Date of publication: 2023-12-15 13:41:03
Date of submission: 2023-10-15 18:04:43


Statistics


Total abstract view - 869
Downloads (from 2020-06-17) - PDF (Русский) - 299

Indicators



Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Copyright (c) 2023 Svetlana Shnitman-Mcmillin

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.