Russian Resentment: Its Application in the Case of Ukraine

Vitalij Makar, Yuriy Makar

Abstract


According to the German philosopher Friedrich Nietzsche, resentment means a feeling of resentment and hostility towards those who – in the subjective sense – are responsible for someone else’s failures. Russia as a state and Russian society often attribute the blame for their problems to external factors, instead of looking for it within themselves. Therefore, the authors use the concept of resentment to analyze the Russian attitude towards Ukraine and Ukrainians. The full-scale aggression of Russia against Ukraine is justified by its organizers as the need to regain something allegedly lost. To this end, the history of Ukrainian statehood has been completely falsified, and its significance has been diminished against the background of the Russian historical narrative. The authors analyze Russia’s actions aimed at denying the existence of an independent Ukraine, repeated attempts to ban the Ukrainian language, and imposing a Russian version of Orthodoxy. The contempo rary expression of these aspirations is the ideology of the so-called “Russian peace.”

Keywords


resentment, Russian aggression, special military operation, ban on the Ukrainian language, Ukrainian statehood, Russian statehood

References


Документи

Ukrainska Tsentralna Rada. Dokumenty i materialy u dvokh tomakh, T. 1: 4 bereznia – 9 hrudnia 1917 r., Kyiv 1996.

Інтернет-джерела

Istoriia Rusi, yaku my ne znaiemo. Koly naspravdi zasnuvaly Kyiv? https://www.youtube.com/ watch?v=S6P0g_UBeWw.

Kovtun O., Rosiiskyi resentyment, abo chomu Rosiia vbyvaie ukraintsiv, https://nv.ua/ukr/opinion/viynarosiji-za-shcho-rosiyani-nenavidyat-ukrajinciv-genocid-novini-ukrajini-50232868.html.

Konflikt shchodo ostrova Tuzla, ttps://uk.wikipedia.org/wiki/Konflikt-shchodo-ostrova-Tuzla.

«Nykakoho Krыma Khrushchev Ukrayne ne daval»: Nyna Khrushcheva — kak byohrafyia deda povlyiala na naslednykov, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=53JcTI5V07I.

Portnykov, V., Peredacha Krymu Ukraini: tse buv ne Khrushchov, „Radio Svoboda”, https://www. radiosvoboda.org/a/29056184.html.

Putin rozpovidav Sholtsu, shcho Ukraina ye chastynoiu Rosii – ISW, „Radio Svoboda”, https://www. radiosvoboda.org/a/news-putin-sholts-ukrajina-chastyna-rosijiu/32966491.html

Poshyrennia idei «russkoho myra» v Ukraini, https://vue.gov.ua/Russkyi_myr

Pravoslavna Tserkva Ukrainy: shliakh kriz viky, https://www.pomisna.info/uk/tserkva/istoriya/

«Rosiiska sproba zlamaty khrebet ukrainskoi natsii»: doktor istorychnykh nauk z Donechchyny pro Holodomor, https://v-variant.com.ua/article/holodomor-na-skhodi-antyfeyk/

«SRSR nemozhlyvo uiavyty bez Ukrainy». Yak Mykhailo Horbachov do ostannoho chynyv opir ukrainskii nezalezhnosti, „Forbes”, https://forbes.ua/inside/srsr-nemozhlivo-uyaviti-bez-ukraini-yakmikhaylo-gorbachov-do-ostannogo-chiniv-opir-ukrainskiy-nezalezhnosti-31082022-8041

stolittia represii. Yak ukrainsku movu namahalys vbyty 134 razy,

Vsviti,https://vsviti.com.ua/ society/70620

Штрихи к портрету путиниста. Продолжение темы в постах Фейсбука, https://enovosty.com/politika/ full/1104-shtrixi-k-portretu-putinskogo-orka-prodolzhenie-temy-v-postax-fejsbuka.

Yak Moskva zaprovadzhuvala v Ukraini derusyfikatsiiu,https://www.bbc.com/ukrainian/articles/

c6pv0y3xpxlo

Yak Moskoviia stala Rosiieiu? Do 300-littia «vykradennia» nazvy ukrainskoho narodu, „Radio Svoboda”, https://www.radiosvoboda.org/a/ukrayina-rus-i-moskoviya/31521000.html.

Дослідження

Vynar L., Bibliohrafichnyi pokazchyk (1948-2007), Lviv-Ostroh-Niu York-Paryzh, 2007.

Kennedy Р., The Rise and Fall of the Great Powers: Economic Changes and Military Conflict from 1500 to 2000, Pulisher: Random House, 1987, 677 р.

Lysiak-Rudnytskyi I., Mizh istoriieiu ta politykoiu. Statti do istorii ta krytyky ukrainskoi suspilno-politychnoi dumky, Vydavnytstvo «Suchasnist», 1973.

Lenin V. I., Manifest k ukrainskomu narodu s ul’timativnymi trebovaniyami k Ukrainskoy Rade, PSS, t. 35, Moskva.

Lenin V. I., Razvitiye kapitalizma v Rossii, PSS, t. 3, Moskva: Izdatel’stvo politicheskou Literatury,1967.

Lazarovych M., Myronenko P., Moskovsko-ukrainska viina (2014-2024 roky), Kyiv: Politiia, 2024, 519 ss.

Plokhii S., Rosiisko-ukrainska viina. Povernennia istorii, Kharkiv: KSD, 2023, 399 ss.

Makar Yu., Sto rokiv tomu i teper: namahannia RF utrymaty Ukrainu v sferi svoikh heopolitychnykh interesiv [v:] Ukraińcy i ich sąsiedzi na przestrzeni wieków: polityka, gospodarka, religia, kultura i życie codzienne, Т.ІІІ, red. nauk. R. Drozd, B. Halczak, Słupsk–Warszawa 2022, s. 397-399.

Slavutych Ya., Doslidzhennia ta statti. Rozstriliana muza. Mech i pero. Ukrainska literatura na zakhodi, Edmonton 2006, 484 ss.




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.17951/we.2024.10.2.41-56
Date of publication: 2025-03-11 20:05:52
Date of submission: 2025-03-11 13:15:54


Statistics


Total abstract view - 168
Downloads (from 2020-06-17) - PDF (Українська) - 0

Indicators



Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Copyright (c) 2025 Vitalij Makar, Yuriy Makar

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.